Costco’s cheese section is a haven for cheese lovers, offering everything from classic sandwich slices to artisanal selections perfect for a charcuterie board. With such a wide array of options, it can be tricky to know which varieties truly stand out. Thankfully, seasoned shoppers are eager to share their insights on the most delicious and high-quality cheeses the warehouse has to offer.
Earlier this week, a Costco enthusiast sparked a lively discussion on Reddit by asking fellow members to share their favorite cheese picks. The responses poured in, with hundreds of passionate comments highlighting the top fromage finds at Costco.
Among all the cheeses mentioned in the thread, none garnered more praise than the Kirkland Signature Coastal English Cheddar. This crowd-favorite (120 calories per serving) is aged for up to 15 months, delivering a unique flavor profile that balances sweet and sharp notes. What sets it apart is its distinctive parmesan-like "crunch," created by crystals formed during the aging process—a texture and taste combination that shoppers can’t get enough of.
“My current favorite: English Coastal Cheddar,” one Redditor shared. “It’s fantastic but a bit unique—it has tiny crunchy crystals and crumbles perfectly into salads or as a topping for entrées.”
Another commenter added, “It has a nice sharp flavor but still melts beautifully.”
Another standout frequently mentioned in the thread was the Kirkland Signature Sartori Bellavitano Cabernet Sauvignon Cheese (110 calories per serving). This cheese, described on the packaging as “full-bodied and a little nutty,” is infused with Kirkland Signature Cabernet Sauvignon, making it a beloved choice among members for its rich, distinctive flavor.
“If you haven’t tried it yet, you absolutely have to. It doesn’t taste like wine—it’s fantastic,” one shopper raved about the cheese.
Another enthusiast chimed in, “I was just about to mention this cheese! Oh my gosh, it’s the best, especially paired with grapes and crackers.”
As it turns out, Kirkland Signature is behind several of Costco’s most beloved cheeses. Many members also heaped praise on the Kirkland Signature Brie (101 calories per serving), a rich and creamy cheese sold in 1.32-pound wheels and imported straight from France.
“Kirkland Brie is the best! Whether served as is or baked, it’s always a hit,” one Redditor exclaimed.
Other Costco cheeses earning high praise include the Kirkland Signature Greek Organic Feta (90 calories per serving), Jarlsberg Semi-Soft Part-Skim Cheese, Kirkland Signature Italian Parmigiano Reggiano (110 calories), and the entire Tillamook brand. With so many varieties highlighted in the Reddit thread, it seems shoppers would be hard-pressed to find a Costco cheese that disappoints. For even more recommendations, readers can dive into the full Reddit discussion or explore our taste test of 10 popular Costco cheeses.